This week I watched the film, October 8, with two dear Jewish friends. It began with the atrocities of October 7, 2023 when Hamas launched an attack on unarmed Israeli civilians, murdering, raping and taking hostages. The film footage and reports point to atrocities that cannot be dismissed or justified – Hamas undermined the cause of the Palestinians and brought untold harm to them. The film then highlights the protests on college campuses against Israel and for Palestinians and the treatment of Jews on college campuses that left Jewish students afraid. I appreciated the film for highlighting the experience of these students and the extreme anti-Zionism that was sometimes expressed in these protests.
As with so much in our world today, the film captures in a compelling way one perspective on the truth (another, I have not seen, called The Encampments, attempts to tell another perspective). I agree with October 8 it as far as it goes – the horrors of October 7 cannot be ignored. Protestors carrying Hamas flags and people celebrating the actions of Hamas on October 7 feels unthinkable and immoral in the light of the atrocities. And people threatening Jewish students on social media and students being afraid on their college campuses should never happen. For most Jews, seeing the marches and seeing signs supporting Hamas in the light of the atrocities of October 7 is frightening. It felt like the antisemitism that has historically been present in America was returning. I was struck by a quote attributed to Irish writer Conor Cruise O’Brien, “Antisemitism is a very light sleeper.”
The atrocities of October 7 cannot be justified, but they must be understood in the light of the experience of Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank over the last 75 years. I did not understand this as an American Christian until I began traveling to the Holy Land 30 years ago and spending part of that time in Palestinian villages like Bethlehem, Jericho, Nablus (biblical Sychar where Jesus met the woman at the well) and others. It was interviewing Palestinians, breaking bread with them, listening to them describe their experiences, seeing them pass through checkpoints that treated them as prisoners in their own land that opened my eyes to another side of this story. It was hearing a doctor who spoke here at Resurrection several years ago as part of the Seven Days of Kindness describe walking into his bombed home in Gaza finding the dismembered bodies of his daughters after an IDF attack that targeted the wrong house, and other stories that led me to see the Palestinian side I’d never understood.
Which side is true? They are both true, and there are grave injustices on both sides. Injustice breeds injustice. Someone recently criticized me for my “both-siderism” – I think that was the term they used. Sometimes there are not two sides – there is only injustice. But often there are two sides, or two perspectives, to each story. Our tendency as humans is to hear one side and miss the other, to regurgitate something we’ve heard or read and not take the time to actually find out if it is true, or what may also be true on the other side.
When it comes to Palestinians and Israelis, understanding both sides leads me to compassion for the Palestinian people in the light of their history of displacement and marginalization. It leads me to abhor the fact that 60,000+ Palestinians have been reported killed in the last 19 months and a huge number of people have had their homes destroyed. I can’t look at the photos of the devastation in Gaza and not be moved. I’m disturbed when I hear of settlers in the West Bank harassing Palestinians, destroying their homes, and cutting down their olive trees. And seeing the photos this week of emaciated children starving in Gaza angers me.
Understanding both sides also leads me to say that atrocities in the name of fighting injustice (i.e. the October 7th attack) only compound injustice (or, as we learned growing up, “two wrongs don’t make a right”). It leads me to understand that most Jews in Israel want peace and justice for both themselves and Palestinians. They don’t want children dying of starvation. But they also don’t ever again want to see their friends murdered in an atrocity like October 7. There will never be peace for Israel until there is fairness (justice) and a just resolution for the Palestinian. And there will never be peace and prosperity for the Palestinians until there is a willingness to accept and find ways to partner with Israel.
I am against terrorism and violence perpetrated by Hamas, and I am against the atrocities that have been perpetrated against Palestinians in the name of rooting out Hamas. I am for doing whatever must be done to ensure food aid is being received by those who need it in Gaza, and for seeing that people are not starving to death as we say nothing. (And yes, I have read the Jewish Federations paper published yesterday claiming the fault is not with Israel, but with aid agencies, distribution processes and Hamas – as well as several articles published in the last few days by the Jewish Israeli newspaper Haaretz offering somewhat differing views).
Understanding both sides of this and other complex issues means not watching only Fox News or MSNBC and believing you have the whole story. It includes doing some homework and actively and empathetically seeking to listen to people whose perspectives may differ from your own. And, in the face of a wrong, with humility and grace, making your voice heard and when you can do more, to do more. In a time when there are so many things happening that are troubling, none of us can research and study every issue. But as often as possible make it your aim to understand before forming an opinion, to seek balanced sources of information, and when you have an informed opinion on something that is bringing harm to others, speak up as Proverbs 31:8-9 tells us, “Speak out on behalf of the voiceless, and for the rights of all who are vulnerable. Speak out in order to judge with righteousness and to defend the needy and the poor.”
THIS WEEK’S PODCAST: WILL THERE BE PETS IN HEAVEN?
In this week’s episode of my podcast Making Sense of Faith, I tackle this question that I’m frequently asked. We’ll explore what Scripture reveals about this, some personal stories, and I’ll reflect on how our beloved pets can deepen our understanding of God’s character and offer profound hope. I hope you’ll share this with your pet-loving friends. To listen to it, click here.